“Can my last employer stop me taking a job?”
If you’ve been dismissed from your previous employment, you might think you can take the first job you’re offered. But that might not be the case. As with many legal situations, it depends on the contract that’s in place at the time.
What does your contract say?
When you joined your last company, you will have been given an employment contract – you might know it as your ‘terms and conditions’ of employment. If you were a director, you might have had a director’s service agreement. If your past employer made any changes to your contract while you worked there, you would have had to agree to them in writing.
When you left that company, you might have accepted a settlement agreement (or compromise agreement in Northern Ireland) – that’s another contract.
Check your contract and look for a section headed ‘Restricted covenants’ or ‘Post-termination restrictions’.
In that section, your last employer might say:
- You can’t get a job at a similar business
- You can’t set up a competing business
The restriction might only last for a certain amount of time, or apply within a selected geographic area.
If your written contract doesn’t mention anything like this, or if you only had a verbal contract, you can accept whatever new job you’re offered.
Why might a restrictive covenant apply?
Working at your past employer probably gave you insight about the business which gives you a competitive edge, especially if you were in a senior, highly skilled, or customer-facing role.
It would be vital to your past employer to protect their business information or customer relationships, so restrictive covenants are quite normal in this situation.
Restrictive covenants are more likely if your job meant you had access to trade secrets, confidential or competitor-sensitive information, or if there’s a risk you might take customers, suppliers or staff with you to your new job.
Instead of working your notice before you left your old company, you might have been put on garden leave. This means you’d receive full pay and benefits but you didn’t have to go to work. Employers sometimes do this:
- To prevent you starting a new job until your notice period expires
- To stop you having access to up-to-date confidential information
- So they can quickly recruit your successor
Note that your employer can only put you on garden leave if it’s expressly stated in your contract.
Types of restrictive covenant
There are four main types of restrictive covenant:
- Non-compete
- Non-solicitation
- Non-dealing
- Non-poaching
The period of time each restriction applies could range from three months to one year, depending on your level of seniority.
Let’s look at each of them in turn:
As you’d imagine, a non-compete clause prevents you from working for a competitor or setting up a business that competes with your past employer.
These clauses can be difficult to enforce, as your past employer would have to prove that your new work would lose them business. Much as they might want to, no company can’t forbid the idea of competition altogether.
A non-solicitation clause prevents you from soliciting clients, customers or contacts of your past employer – that means you can’t approach those people with a view to moving them to your new employer, no matter how close your personal connection with them has been.
A non-dealing clause means you can’t have any contact at all with any clients, customers or contacts of your past employer. It doesn’t make a difference whether you approach them, or they approach you.
This type of clause is more likely to be upheld if it only applies to clients you’ve had ‘material dealings’ with in the past 12 months, say, rather than all clients, ever. The clause will be hard to enforce if it attempts to prevent you from dealing with relevant business contacts while not affecting your past employer’s business.
A non-poaching clause prevents you from inviting your former colleagues to join you at your new employer or startup business.
This can also apply when your new employer has recruited a whole team from your ex-employer.
Are the restrictions reasonable?
Your past employer can’t stop you getting a new job (or starting a new business) out of malice.
Any restrictive covenants must therefore be ‘reasonable’. That means they should be designed to protect your past employer’s ‘legitimate business interest’ and prevent them from losing money. They must be able to justify the restrictions they want to put in place.
Restrictions that are unreasonable might include:
- A restriction that’s broader than required to protect business interests
- A restriction that lasts more than six months (unless that’s standard in your sector)
- A restriction that prevents you from working in a certain area when your old company doesn’t operate there
- A restriction that stops you from working at a company that doesn’t compete with your old employer
- A restriction that prevents you from getting any job at all – your ex-employer can’t deny you the right to make a living in your chosen sector
An unreasonable restriction would be void and unenforceable.
Here are some more examples:
- If other employees who do the same job as you do not have the same restrictive covenants in their contracts
- If, for some reason, you never signed your employment contract
- If you joined the company at a junior level and the restrictive covenants in your contract at the time would have been unenforceable
- If a restrictive covenant was added to your contract but you were not paid a ‘consideration’ in return for accepting it – this might be by way of continued employment, increased salary, a bonus, or promotion to a new job title
If your past employer imposed a restrictive covenant without your express consent, and you felt forced to resign as a result, you might be able to make a claim for constructive dismissal – however, these cases can be hard to win, so it’s best not to resign without taking legal advice first.
If your past employer terminated your employment and reemployed you on different terms that now include a restrictive covenant, you might be able to make a claim for unfair dismissal – your employer will have to prove they did it for legitimate business reasons.
What can you do?
If you’re facing a restrictive covenant, there are various options – we can help with any or all of them, as required.
We are employment lawyers who only ever act for employees. We specialise in helping employees get a fair deal.
1. Negotiate your way out of it
Your past employer might not understand exactly what your new job entails. When you explain that it doesn’t impact their business, you can try to get the restriction removed or reduced.
To help get the result you want, you’d need to understand what aspect of the business your past employer is trying to protect through the restriction. For example, you could reassure them that you:
- Won’t harm their business
- Won’t poach their staff, suppliers or customers
- Will keep their confidential information secret
2. Negotiate with your new employer
Your new employer might agree to be flexible until the restriction expires. For example, they might allow you to delay your start date, arrange for you to do different work for a while, or base you at another site to start with.
3. Ignore the restriction
If you ignore the restriction, your past employer can take you – and your new employer – to court, in order to prevent you from doing your new job.
In England, Wales and Northern Ireland, this is known as an ‘injunction’. In Scotland, it’s called ‘interdict’.
If they win, here are some of the things they can do:
- Ask you to destroy confidential information that you hold
- Demand repayment of profits they’ve lost due to your actions
- Sue your new employer for damages
Legal action would cost your past employer time, effort and money, so they will only go down this route if it’s in their commercial interests. However, if they do, you’ll need legal support (we can provide that for you). You’ll also need to collect detailed written evidence to back up your case, so it’s wise to keep copies of everything that’s relevant.
Related reading
- Should I accept a settlement agreement?
- Is my settlement agreement tax-free?
- When is a compromise agreement used?
- Help! I’ve been told to find a new job. What should I do?
- I’ve been dismissed from my new job. Can I claim unfair dismissal?
Need help?
For a FREE assessment of your case, call 0808 168 7288 or complete a Free Online Enquiry.
We have already helped thousands of people to win millions of pounds in compensation.
You have a choice of ways to pay, including ‘no win, no fee’.